Welcome to our website!
Feb. 3, 2025

Best Cards of Non Hall of Fame Players Card Mensches E57

Best Cards of Non Hall of Fame Players Card Mensches E57
Sports Card Nation Podcast
Best Cards of Non Hall of Fame Players Card Mensches E57

John is back and we tackle the best baseball cards of players not in the Hall of Fame.



"Card Mensches" Brought to you by SGC and The Pennysleever.com



A new format for Sports Talk and Sports Cards!"

Join us live every other Friday for our great and interactive chat room. We definitely have fun!

linktr.ee/cardmensches

linktr.ee/sportsbalt

https://linktr.ee/Sportscardna...



Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/sports-card-nation-podcast--4761791/support .

0:00 Hey everyone, John Newman here, thank you for downloading this episode of Card Matches. Myself and Danny Black of hobby News Daily would like to remind you this is a live show every other Friday at nine pm Eastern. It can be found on most of our social medias, Danny's at sports Ball and hobby News Daily. I am Sportscardination Podcast, and it can be found on our YouTube channels at hobby News Daily, Sportscarnation Podcast at sports Ball, and at Card Matches. So with that being said, we hope to see you very soon on a Friday night in our very active chat room. Now let's start the show.

0:43 It's quality consistent and the quickest turnaround times and the grating and we are proud to partner with SGC. Check them out at www dot go SGC dot com. Experience quality, consistent and the quickest turnaround times and the grating and we are proud to partner with SGC. Check them out at www dot go SGC dot com. Hi. Hi'm Issa Calper, a longtime card and the co founder of the Pennies. My wife and I started the Pennies with a simple premise in mind to offer collectors top quality supplies at fair We offer a full range of hobbies and we'll get them be fast. Whether you're looking for a two hundred magnetic for that oversized or slew of semigrad you next submission. The Penny Sleever has a shop now at the Pennysleever dot com and use the promo code sc nation to get ten percent off. That's sc for ten percent off at the Pennies dot com.

1:35 The Pennies Top Quality supply, Fair Price. I am dead in luck and I'm John Newman. Welcome to Carton Man. What's up? What is going on? No pinch matches today? I back in the lineup. I don't know if I'm new and approved. I'm just the same, but I'm just here. About that filling in for John Newman? Is John Newman? Yeah, I'm pinch hitting for the Pinch Hitters episode fifty seven.

2:19 Like the set you're trying to put together. We agreed on this topic, which I think is a good one. Best baseball cards of non Hall of Famers. I'll just say I've got eleven, eleven or twelve cards on my list, and probably sixty seventy percent of them are sort of like chalk picks. What you expect would be the same on a lot of other people's lists, and then there's some that might be off the beaten path. So I'll just say that with my list. I'm also hoping, first of all, held on to everybody on the Stewart's Ruben Good Evening. I roughly came up with a small list as per the shows on Loving that.

3:00 Yeah you got it interactive you gotta. And I know you guys don't believe it. John and I have not shared our full list with each other. No, I we don't like to do that. I think it's we like the spot naighty. Obviously, some of the picks are gonna be the same. They just that's you know, you get a list of ten to fifteen, you're not gonna have all different You're not gonna have thirty. You know, if we each have fifteen, we're not gonna have thirty different cards. You know, last we shared our list and made a point out there. This is this is all honest and organic. What's up? Hodges appreciate it. If you like this video, give it a like and a follow. Ruben's like, I'm starting to show without you guys. Yeah, Ruby, you're gonna leave us on the dove would normally John and I try to figure out who's gonna go first.

3:47 Rubs Like you guys talk too much. Let's here we go. Yeah, let's just think of the car he. Hit lift off. He's like three two. One, no, no, no four player for Ruben. Gets right into it. Hey man, and safe time. Well do you want to start with the one that we agreed? Well, we think it's the most often. Yeah. Yeah, and that's a good one by by Orlando right off the top. It didn't make my list. I will say that you won't see it. Yeah, all right, here we go. This is this is chalk right, this sixty three tops Pete Rose, rookie. This card acts like pizza in the hall already, and we all know at this moment he's not and we just lost him. I'm hoping.

4:34 I always said that the Hall is going to put him in when he passes away, and so now we're at that point, and I just wonder if and when, like will that will that Newman prophecy come true? Because that's what I think was the plan all along. Hasn't happened yet. So this card qualifies for this list. I mean, but when you try to buy this card, and I got to say, I don't own one of the at the moment, and sometimes I'll search for one, and this thing is priced as if Pete's already in the Hall, and I get it. Like, no one's arguing whether Pete Rose is a Hall of Famer. It's just the band that's preventing it, you know, like when we have debates, you know, Dave Parker, Steve Garvey about whether they're hallworthy or whoever, Harold Baines is no insert or whatever name.

5:23 Pete Rose will never be on that list. Pete Rose is only not in the Hall for the one major reason. That's your question. What do you think the odds are he gets in? Like what's the time span, like ever five to ten years? Well, I think he does now that. Unfortunately he's no longer with us, you know, because you I mean the guys that you know, he is an easy Hall of Famer. If he was on the ballot, he should be unanimous, if you take away what happened, and he was just on the as a player, there being one that shouldn't vote. No. Yeah, I mean part of me says he did it to himself. The other part of me says he's paid his due and it's time to let him in.

6:09 So so, yeah that one you picked that too, right. Yeah, I had, I had it also. I think that's one of the one of the ones. Now I will throw a Ruben's list up real quick, and I will say some of these are online, not not all of them by anyone. Let's see, I'm trying to count man one of these Ruben's gonna like, I'm gonna be off the Christmas card list that I'm not on. So card menches, card menches, Okay, well, then do you want to lead it off on the non chalk cards even though we have the other one? Later? All right, this one, I don't know how many, you know, I don't know how many people would have this kind.

6:53 It would probably make a few people's list. Anyone that's heard my content knows I'm a fanboy and lover of this card and it is iconic, and it is a guy that's obviously not in the hall. Maybe that should be I dig you and I love this card. That costs me a lot of money chasing chasing it back in nineteen eighty four, but there it is. Eighty four Doners died madly. This would be one of my favorite cards with no qualifiers, So the fact that we make a qualified guys not in the hall this really shot up my list. I'm not gonna even say it's my number one card, but it's pretty close to it. And everyone knows I like big face rookies and I cannot lie.

7:36 And this is, you know, Griffy eighty nine upper deck, this one I'm always saving. That's the only thing. If they and if they ever making like a like a heritage version, and if they asate, I'm not gonna lie. Even though I don't buy a lot of new stuff, I might cross the picket line that day. I stood away from this because I knew you were. Gonna you did. Yeah, yeah, this is like low hanging. I mean it's New York. I was happy to skip. Yeah, even Orioles fans though, like he wasn't a trade. And I love this card. Actually, the eighty four tops maningly was was in the first box I ever broke before top.

8:21 The problem I have with this card today is when I get him, I don't want to sell them. No matter how many I have, I'm always like, I'm gonna keep them all And then I'm like, how many do you need? Newman? So they always eventually some of them make it back into the Dealer showcase of mind. But there's I'm in this room. Is what I'm looking at. I can see it from on the wall, not behind me over there. I'll give John a chance to read this and laugh at me. We haven't talked about this yet, uh yet. Now, Justin Tucker is not in my pet. You know what, he made my fan not this year but past years. And he made like he got me in a couple of Fantasy League playoffs because like that's tough for a Steeler fan. But he you know, maybe not this year, but best kicker of football.

9:11 Maddy Ka even today, eighty four stretched me as one of the most attractive sets ever. That was the year Dunros made the leap. Yep, I think there's. Think about think about the couple releases before eighty four donners and then put them up against it, like it's like single A the major leagues, Like I don't know what happened early. I don't know what happened. Yeah, I don't know what happened in late eighty three and where I'd love to know the story if anyone knows, and lots of comments like what was the story, like did they have a new designer? You know, after two terrible years? Where did this come out? Left field? Literally?

9:53 Yeah, well I definitely left you maddeningly Well, yeah. That one, and that one was probably one of the first ones I wrote down. I'm gonna throw another one up. Will you throw up the one you haven't uh with the orange background because now somebody yeah, somebody mentioned it in the. Chat nineteen fifty eight. Roger merris Man. There's obviously his rookie, you know, another one of those guys that you can debate both sides should be in. Here's why he's not, you know, I kind of I'm I'm you know, Roger merris had one of the greatest years in basement. It's not the year before, and the year after warn't bad either. People forget that. Yeah, walk the back MVP.

10:39 I will say this, I'm not a stickler. In other words, I'm not crushed that he's not in the hall, and I wouldn't be crushed or against it if it came out that he would inducted, Like I don't. I don't feel strung. I'm sort of on the fence sort of as he is. So whatever happens, I'm not waving a pennant against it or forties Like if he gets in, i won't be like, oh man, they dropped the ball here. And if he doesn't get in, I'm not saying, man, it's such a Travis like it's a crime. I don't know. I'm embarrassed. I forgot this card. Good good, good call in your in yours? Yeah, this card has you know, based on the criteria, guy not in the hall. You know this could change if like Rose gets in that that Rose rookie comes off to Roger Merris gets inducted by the Veteran Committee.

11:25 This card no longer qualifies. But at the moment, like I had to put it on here. Well, and this is true. You can't tell the history of baseball without mentioning. Roger May It is true. I mean, if it's in, if it's in ken Burns, then to qualifies. Yeah, I'm gonna pull it off. I'm gonna want me to pull it off. Here there the Chad is doing a great job of Nellen some tonight. Yeah, they're like they're like they're they're sniffing out my picks. Well, not only that, I was gonna take a turn, and my first one on my list was fourteen fifteen whichever you prefer, the Shoeless Jill cracker Jack.

12:06 All right, yeah, that's a nice car. I'm not gonna argue with that. Yeah. And here's another guy that should be in the hall. All the reports say, you know, wasn't in on this Black Sox scandal and then obviously a Hall of Fame worthy outside of that. And here's another guy. I think if Pete Rose ever gets in, Shoeless gets it, can you imagine that year. Unfortunately they're both no. Longer with It wouldn't be a lot of speeches. No, but you know, you'd have obviously family representation, you'd have some baseball historians, you know, maybe coming up there and like saying, hey, it's about time, and then take out all the other stuff. These were two of the greatest players. Another great pick there by by Stukes, the uker.

12:53 But he's in. We talked about that. Oh yeah, this does not qualify Stukes like it's a great pick. I'm not picking on you. He actually's in. I was not sure either. I had to ask Dandy Dan I thought he was, and sure enough, he was in the in the media. Win and I'll say to the chat also, the greatest induction speech in the history of induction speeches. You'll laugh the whole time if waun till we're finished at least, but then go on, don't. Leave yeteve because yeah, I'll make you laugh a couple of times. Maybe it's not as much as you care, but I'll give it my I'll give it the old college tries as so. Anyway, So the cracker Jack Shoeless Joe. I think it's a classic card. It's artwork, and I yeah, it's.

13:38 A great pick. It was on my list, but then I wanted I'm always the first card guy or rookie, right, So I'm gonna put this up now because I got a shoeless Joe. Okay for this one. This is the American Caramel from nineteen oh oh nine. And this isn't my card. I stole this photo. You don't need to hook me up to a live detective confess because I don't own this card. But like, how cool was this card? Man? He's leaning on the bat, you know, pre war. Well, obviously you're you're gonna find most of these well loved and beat up unless you want to take out your check book or mortgage your house. But it's just a great card from of a great player.

14:18 Who again, you know when we were like, like it was said before, when we when we tell the story of baseball, right, Jules, Joe's in the two and not just for the you know, the Black Sox candal, for his prowess as a player as well. So uh yeah, this is a sassy pose. He's like, I'm sureless, Joe, what what's up? Fellas? And this picture can talk, That's what it would say. You don't even know what's coming. That's what he's thinking. Yeah. Another one by Stukes that I own and I didn't put it on the list. I own this card. It was on my list. I didn't put it on my list. And and say again that is why we have the greatest chat room now, I sort of like I feel gift.

15:00 It's a Brooklyn Dodger to that, Like the reason is rubber bands, so you know. True, true, it's not the the prowess. PavCo had a pretty good arm. If you're a Brooklyn Dodger fan, you know that. Yeah, without the scarcity though he doesn't make any place. Lost yeah, I'm gonna I'm gonna take the shoelace off. Yeah, hopefully he gets in. Man, I'm you know, I think he should be in in the hall. I thought that they had had done a lot of investigating and I thought he was clear. Maybe I'm wrong. The rumor is there's no way he could have been in on it. He had like big numbers, He had like higher numbers in the World Series and as regulars, like, how do you do that if you're you know, there's reports he tried to talk his teammates out of doing it and like do this so you know, no one knows.

15:53 I guess for sure, but listen, man, with those kind of numbers in the World Series, he's throwing and Judge would sign up for that. Yeah, really, you know? So so put the guy in, Like it's a shame he's not around to enjoy the accolade. But put the dude in. Put p Rose in. Now, I know. I got in a debate at the last show, just not a not for long ten minutes with a guy that real like it came up. I had a card or something. He's like, he shouldn't be in the hall. Passed away the band the band ends when you pass away, like when you die in prison, they don't bury you on the prison grounds. They give your remains to your family and you're outside the prison. So that's the analogy. Maybe not the best one.

16:39 But if the prison of the banishment of the Hall was because he was alive when he dies, he gets outside the put him in. No one will argue, you know, apparently never bet against the Reds like he was throwing. More than price. He did. He did, and I'm not saying he's the best guy in the world and not for so you know, and there's eighteen million Pete Rose autographs because the dude, I think he's still signing quite frankly, they're just dropping down. But put the like, put him in, like you said, he served this time, I'll die on that hill. And I'm not even I'm not good. I have a certified expert.

17:31 I took the master the Master class. And well cemetery, so you know I've been. To a couple. Yeah. Uh, put the guy in, like you know, no one can argue Pete Rose the player shouldn't be in there. I mean, Pete Rose was baseball for a good stretch of basement like he was like any commercial and any anything. He was the cover boy. Like you said, he paid his price, We didn't pay his ice. You know, then I could say, well, you know that's not paid back yet. He just cracks me up because I think it's true and funny. I'm sure there's still three million sticker artos sitting in the warehouse waiting for said products. There's no shorting five Feller Pete Rose, I think are the two most. That's how they're out there.

18:20 That's what they're doing upstairs, you know it. Yeah, I'm sure they're signings at the gates. They ask you when you get there, would you like it? Pete Rose or Bob? Yeah? Really it comes in the gift bag sponsored by what. Moving on, speaking of prison and breving on, Yeah, I think we're off the rare house. It took what twenty one minutes? We're there, Peter Rose, Bob Feller. That was like a show. That's that's you know who it is. It's that kid from the sandwa it's.

19:02 The Sandlot group. Because they're not doing sand Lot too. Return return of Squints not happening. So if you're now hope they you know what the only thing they might do, which won't help the Really the older Sandlight guys. They might do a new Sandlot with like child actors today, but the old Sandlot kids would be like, what do we get out of that? Unless they make them adults in the movies. Sometimes they do that where they put like they redo a movie and an actor that was a kid in the movie plays an adult world. So maybe they can give those guys jobs on Sandlot too, not as themselves or maybe as themselves grown up. And these are the their kids playing terrible script. That's why I'm in Syracuse and not Hollywood. But there you go.

19:50 They running out ideas though they're redoing every single movie. Hey, send them a script. You never know. Ye guys go up, the kids go up to have kids, and now we do. Actually that's one page. That's one page. Doc Gooden is always signing, and so is Laurence Taylor. That gooda No, he sometimes steps and doesn't show. He might be advertised a lot, but he's a famous like cancelation or notion. Orlando says, sticks a card to collecting John. I'm trying, Orlando, be careful. Your next personal hobby hotline will be November. Speaking of movies, though, I did have a director of a new hobby. I'm gonna be talking to him. Got to screen the movie. The movie's actually pretty good.

20:37 That's awesome. That's good stuff. Whose turn is it? You can go, you can go. I'm gonna get a couple of morty. I'm gonna throw out Tommy john Rook. He's sixty four tops. I just I have complete respect for what Tommy john did. Look at his numbers after his surgery, the amount of years he pitched, and his surgery is not like today. I mean they they were in there cutting apart and sewing together in a whole different way than they do it now. I just think it's amazing. And he was willing to be the guinea pig and he was and that takes balls. So I think he deserves to be in the Hall of Fame on his numbers, but certainly for having the surgery named after you. I mean it's Tommy Johnson.

21:22 Yeah, I'm gonna be honest with you this one. This one didn't really make my list. I think Tommy john was a very good picture, good to very good picture. I think just pitched no time. You know a he does have his name on the surgery is that enough to get you on my list. I said no, but I won't argue with he He's probably a borderline Hall of Fame. The borderline. Yeah, if anybody looks some of his numbers, you'll be surprised. He's a lot closer than than I think people realize. Two hundred and eighty wins. There you go, Yeah, which nowadays, today's today's picture is if anyone hits two eighty, you know they're in. So again, three hundred was the mark during his era, but that ain't gonna happen any We talked about this on on Hobby Hotline the other day. So, yeah, I can't argue with this. Now you've convinced me. I've kind of like I've dropped down the weapon, and I probably should be in.

22:19 I think he's it's hard to compare pictures for. I'm not saying the guy's a Hall of Famer necessarily, but I have him on my list. I think he deserves to mention. When we did this. Topic, yeah, you know, even when I think enough to make this a Hall of Fame show, like CC doesn't like I really I'm not like like, I'm not picketing, but I don't. I never looked at, you know, especially late in his career. I'm like, I don't, I don't know if he's all of it. He's very good here he is, he's in the hall, is her So you know. He never pitched in your division? No, but I listen, dude, I've played like I know who he is and. Not like no, no, no no. But I'm saying, like, you know, how somethings you see more often, you know, you just a different thing.

23:00 Well, I mean he's going into halls of Yankee so he pitched. You know, I'm not a Yankee fan any longer, but you know, I'm not that far from New York still my hotel, So I just he never you know how you watch a player during the career and you're already making that assessment and you're like, oh man, he's a lock for the hall. I never said that the same thing with like Scott Rowland. I never said with Scott Rowland like this guy's I agree. You know, I put CC in that category. Now, when you really take a step back and look at the body work and the numbers, it's hard to argue against it too, So I get it. It just didn't feel that way watching it live. It's when you look at it after it's over, and you know, it's hard not to put a guy when if you took the name off and I didn't know who it was, and so does player? Are these Hall of Fame worthy? I'd have to say yes.

23:53 The run with Milwaukee, I felt like you knew something special was happening when he when he got trended over there and pitched you know, like every other day for a couple of months, and took it and pulled them into the playoffs. You know, I don't know, he's a close one for me. I'm a small Hall guy anyway. Yeah. Uh, Rubin says CEC was a Hall of Famer in Golden Corral. Like to give a shout out. To shout out to Golden Corral. By the way, we are accepting them as a sponsor if they're interesting. I don't think i've ever ate there a while ago. I don't know how they are. Probably probably just as greasy and and you know, as when you were there. Whose turn is it?

24:38 I'm gonna I'm want to go because I think we talked that we both picked this card. I saw it mentioned in the chat room. A couple of times. Just so you know, kids at home, I didn't block out the bet, but I think that's just a way what this is. Now. No one's gonna argue Billy Ripkin, and I know you get to see him up close or he did get this. Uh. He's not known for his baseball prowers, but this card is one of the most iconic cards of the hobby. And it's not for Billy Ripkins two nineteen career batting average. We all know why. It's a card that's still in demand today thirty five years. How many cards can you say that with that aren't really like vintage like a man O rookie, right, How many cards can you say that with from the eighties that are still this much today? This is one that checks that box. And so, uh, you know that's a great question by Stuke's where did this bat wind up?

25:37 I thought there's different stories, but I thought it was it was just destroyed. To be honest, man, that's a that's tragic. Can you imagine this being in the hall but the hall has to put like a black box over it? In the white box or do they get but they changed it every week? They changed every week in the display case it's the black Blacks week, it's the white scribble week, it's the saw cut week. You know, thank you? Where are you gonna get jokes. Like that right for free? Yeah, I'm telling you that. I don't know. If this bat's destroyed, someone's got to own it.

26:20 Rubin, I'm not even putting that up. That's rough, buddy, he says. Kevin Costner took it to Col's house. Uh, Jason says, we already say the fifty. No, I didn't. Man, I'm gonna be on some people. It's like dartboards. They're gonna be throwing steel tips. That's a good one. Can you imagine that's a I saw someone actually make a fake one? And yeah, yeah, but can you can you imagine if Fanatics acquired the real Billy Ripkin f face card and took the knob off and made like the major League debut patches and one on one and what does that bring We've just seen the Skemes patch card.

27:04 Do you think it's sound religious to cut up that bat? Though? I do, But the Fanatics does a lot of sacredly. So just add that to just add that to the next life and let's just call. It as we see it. Uh yeah, absolutely, you imagine the chase for that. People are chasing the eighty nine Fleer card. It's just a picture. Can you imagine the chase for the actual noob? I just wonder to know how many times you're gonna say nab in one episode. It's a drinking game. Every time I say nab, everyone take a sip or more than one zip. Uh, that's too funny. Yes, we both had Bill Ripkin on the list, so that's why we got it out of the way. That was another one that we to us anyway we thought was chalk.

27:51 Yeah, I do feel seeing some of the choices in the chat room. I'm not gonna lie. I feel guilty. I didn't I didn't put somebody. Yes, sometimes you're looking one way and the curve you know, you're looking fastball and the curveball sneaks in the back door and you're going back. You're walking to the back to the bench, like, how did that happen? So that's what happens when we do we forget. That's why what we love doing, and we learn as much as we you know, share. Uh yeah. Reubenson's fanatics would take a Brooks Robinson game music glove and cut off those bastards. Those bastards soon if they got the copy, the original copy of the Declaration of Independence, there'd be Transit. Transcendent would be set for the next two years. Uh we could uh and they wouldn't even blinket bad and I man.

28:45 The worst part is I love the Transit. Yeah. No, it's a great product if you have the money. I've never opened it. I just don't want to know where. It comes from. Just don't tell me where it came from. The Beatles. There's a I saw one. There's the four Beatles sign. Oh, and that was a cut from something maybe the original record deal. That's it was the night they met when they made Yeah. It was when they formed their middle school band. Right, Who's now? I forgot who's turnative. I put that one out there because I knew we both had it. So it was one man, all right, So next to my list, Okay, I took seventy and seventy one Thurman right, basically because we have no roles and I like both cards for different reasons. You get the rookie and you get the beautiful monthson. I don't know if you picked it.

29:41 That was my only concern. All right, all right, So I'm gonna I'm gonna put up I'm gonna put up a slide here. I put two cards from the seventy one set, one of them. Sorry for the terrible cut and page job, but there's a seven. I don't know why I did that, because I own both of these cards. I just was lazy. They're not out where I can like just grab them, so I just copied. I just copy the paste, so I do. Oh. I own multiple copies actually of each other. So I just cheated and being lazy, and I just copied seventy one. So there you go. Seventy one tops, right, everyone knows these are conditioned sensitive. This one's an in action right with the A's guy sliding across the plate.

30:31 You know, it's just an It's a better looking card than his rookie card, and in many cases it brings more money than his rookie card. That's not what it's about. What stable. Well, it's also ridiculously hard to find in good condition. Yeah, and seventy one Garvey, right, another guy that's on the cusp of the hall. I think he should be in U what is it? Fourteen gold gloves? Or fourteen All Stars. He has something like that, Like that's come on, Like, I'm not saying he's Babe Ruth. I'm not arguing that he's Babe Ruth Tai Coab. I'm just organized in the Hall of Fame. He's welcome to buy a ticket right now. He has to. Well probably not, they probably give him they let him at back door. But yeah, you know, uh no, I no, I did you know, maybe Jason Schwartz was probably more of an influence because we I had him on the podcast that we kind of you know, both took up the flag for probably twenty But this set, it isn't aesthetically great, but because it's black border again, conditions sensitive, and you have Garvey, a guy I think should be in I think it's a great looking card.

31:36 Like the pose he's like kind of in fielding position with his glove on in the months, and it's just a better looking in action card. You know, I think people would say if that could be his, really his rookie card, they sign a petition. So I just picked these two, put them on one slide, two birds, one stone. That's why I said both Munson's because there's the rookie card, but this is the better looking card. Yeah. No, I won't argue with yet, but you know. I mean, listen to me. Is one of the best looking in action shots, you know, in the in the Vinti jerro it is. There's you know, there's people, you know, people think like the fifty two taps is man a rookie. There's people who think that actually is Munson's too. There's a maybe the same group thinks those area and the Johnny Bench, the sixty nine bench, well, because.

32:29 They get confused with the tops All Star Rookie Cup. Yeah. Yeah, a lot of people think those are the rookie Yeah. No, if anybody doesn't know it's an All Star Cup, it means they were an All Star. Yeah, rookie, all right, take it? Sure, alright, Well I did Monson, but I'll throw out another one. Seventy seven Dell Murphy. Yeah, I saw eight reverse negative. I didn't pick any Murphy cards, but for sure, you know he's another guy right on that line, right, I got you know, we talked about guys. I got to see a lot of because the Braves are in the Mets division. I've seen perenty of Murphy's heroics against the Mets growing up into the eighties into early nineties, and so you know, I think he's a Hall of Famer. He used to scare me as a Mets fan, and you know he had a couple of years where he was really the guy in baseball or one of them. He's six score bit Roberts, you know. But if we're doing that, don't forget the nineteen ninety fleeer for your rebay. That's almost one hundred million bucks.

33:39 Hey you Frank Thomas Arrow? Is that on your list? Rebate? Yeah, this is who we're talking about. I lost track or are you you got whoever you want? All right? This is a guy and he's come up in different various versions of this show on different list. This is a guy that I don't like. But when you're putting these lists on, you gotta be honest, right and listen, he's another guy that's not in the Hall. It should be in the Hall for what he did before he start using And this card, I didn't pick the regular one. Let me put it up there eighty six tops traded Barry Bonds with the Tiffany version, and I don't own this card. There's another copy and paste job by your early But I wouldn't mind owning this car now. I'm not actively like going out there trying to get it, but if one crossed my path, and I'm not a Barry Bonds guy, I think he's uh, you know what starts with an A. It's not a nice guy, but one heck of a baseball player before us and then obviously even more after after using But what he did before was definitely Hall of Fame word.

34:52 And it's said that he had to change the direction of the rear in a negative connotation. So this is just gonna be an icon of Carder's. There's people who believe Barry Bonds will eventually be in the Hall and this card will. Obviously it's not cheap now, but it will get it'll get less cheaper if on the day he ever gets. Yeah, I like to use extra words. It makes me sound more intelligent or less intelligent. In that case, I think the Tiffany is a great call. I didn't put it on my list. I came really close, but I decided to stay away from the steroids. Great call on this one. John, Yeah, and I don't like him, like everyone knows.

35:35 That's a classic card. Yeah, I'm just like, I gotta put it on the list. I gotta be. I don't know if you saw, but Orlando says that he has the Tiffany. Yeah, I know. I know he had some Tiffany, so I'm not surprised. And listen, I'm sure he looks. I'm sure he doesn't love the Bonds Part two, but he loves that card, right, and same thing here If I uh and I agree with that, I think they will. You know, I think it's not so much yet. Yeah, yeah, I didn't want to listen. The only reason I would have picked Mossy to put on the screen is just to make myself look slightly less ugly. And I thought that wouldn't be fair. It wouldn't. It would be disingenuous to the list to do that, So I didn't, but the thought was there. He looked like Herman Munster, like when I like hermanns.

36:30 Didn't you use him on our Ugly Card episode? Yeah? I did? That was the low hanging like that? Would that would be on everyone's list that knows him or nose? He looked he always every time I see that card, I think it's Fred Gwynn who played Herman Munster without like they could have hired Don Mossy and saved the whole makeup department budget. Like, just go out there, here's your line, you know, stop your feet, take the cleats off, put these big brick shoes on. Go out there, stop your feet, do a laugh and say Grandpa couple, and then we'll get we'll get you back to this and you won't miss your start y.

37:10 So this just scares me that you should not be night, should be about to watch NICKD. Knight. That's all I'm saying. It's the line of the night from Bookie. I put it up there. Fred Gwyn couldn't hit like Tony. That is very true. He was very tall and his strike zone was too big, and so they'd always get him on the low outside fastball went. To bad funny, too funny. Well, Orlando, guess my next one, so I might as well throw it up. You score, Bo Jackson, bad football baseball. I haven't my case over here. It's one of my favorite cards of all time. I don't care what grade. I don't care. You know, I'll like you said, I pick him up. It's hard to sell them. I just love the card, I think Bo Jackson is one of the greatest athletes I've ever seen in person, and I may ever see in my entire life.

38:11 I just think his athletic ability was beyond beyond, and it's sort of real tragedy that he got hurt. I think we missed out on somebody who would have been just as amazing as a show Hey Tony type of talent. So I'll take the nan Descore black and white bow. Yeah. I like that pick. I didn't pick it, but I think I didn't pick it because I don't know. I knew you would. I knew you would pick I knew you would pick it. It doesn't I like the card. I don't hold it in the same Regala. Oh yeah, that's not the besmirch the card. It's a nicond of card. It's just not it's higher on your list mine. I guess I just saw so many of them that it just they took. It's one of those cards that's bow Climb walls to get balls. Check out rap album Balls to the Wall. It's Dropping Tuesday.

39:05 Also known as where there's a Will, There's Away, the quest to get balls from the wall. Okay, so that's on you, all right. I only have two left, So I'll do. My I'm almost also, so all right, I'll. Do one and then you do one. This one. I tried to go really off grid on this on two of them, and this I think is won't really one of them, although maybe people will disagree. I'll lea me put it on this nineteen thirty three growdy left, the old duel left, the old duel is you know, I was surprised that he's not a Hall of Famer. He has a lifetime batting average of three forty nine. He has the highest batting average career batting average of a person not in the Hall of Fame. Imagine and me his career, he has like over a thousand hits, almost four to at bats or whatever that makes it forty nine bat Remember the era he played in, too, Some of those numbers are not going to match up in today's era. But if you bat three forty nine for your career and you have over three thousand at bats, it's not like he has six hundred at bats and he bated three forty nine. Do you have over three grand in at bats and your lifetime batting average is three forty nine and you're not in the Hall I gotta I gotta disagree with that. So when I thought about poster boys for Hall of Fame cards that are

40:35 not Hall of Fame, this one really, this one really at one of the tops of my my list, and I think when I the reason I put it there is, I'm like, I don't think people realize some of this stuff. So that's one of my you know, if you want to call it educational cards, right, people who don't realize. And I'm not saying Lefty Olduel is an all time great. He was a pitcher too. I believe broke out with the Yankees as a picture. I could be wrong there, but you know, uh, you know what, that had nothing to do with it, Ruben, although I can't prove it. I'm just saying they had nothing to do The three nine, the three forty nine career average was what suaded me with this card. And I will say for the for the numbers this guy put up, this card is actually relatively you know I talked about when we do these lists, right cards then get on my wantless. This car actually jumped onto my wantless because of the significance or the significance to me and the fact that it's not crazy expensive, and you have one of them, and I don't think he ever gets in at this point. Well, come on, man, you know three forty nine lifetime batting it. I don't know what.

41:52 A non alcoholic beer. It was actually disgusted family, so it was. The old Duels. So now he has so the legend grows literally by by the minute. Yeah, they see those an't a great stories, right, I didn't know Rick Stevenson's lifetime, Now I do. Yep. Three, All right, I've got one, but there's two clauses and I need your help on both of them. If I'm correct, Lipmann Pike is not in the Hall of Fame, but I don't know that he has a card other than the historical set that was put out in the eighties or nineties. Oh yeah, that's a card. So if I'm a judge, I say that's good. That's good for the win.

42:40 I'll take Lipmann Pike, who was one of the first stars of baseball. He was the first Jewish star, not the first Jewish star, of the first Jewish athlete who was good in baseball. And other than that one set, he needs cards, never known them. Yeah, I would have been nice to have a pre war Eric Cardos, Right, I would be a little on the pricey side, but it still doesn't make it any less fun, right, Yeah, that counts. I mean I think people will say, well, it's kind of an aftermarket card. It's like the Conlin set, remember that, you know, still a card. Right. My next pick is going to be some people could argue it out. I won't. I won't put it up there. I want to talk about Litman Pike.

43:31 But he was really one of the first baseball superstar, one of the first, and you know, obviously with the name of the show and his nationality and heritage, it's it's definitely a good car. I didn't think of it. I know about the card. I just didn't. I didn't think of it and figured, you know, maybe you know, I tried to stick and playing days as much as just my own criteria. I don't think it's a rule. We talked about it, just my pin down myself. But I like this. I like this pick. Uh, And I. Was gonna say, I just want also one of the Pike to get a little recognition. Yeah, no doubt, no doubt. I don't think I think that's uh, you know, we probably should be in the Hall of Fame, you know, and not on this eligible to be on this list. To begin with, I read a book that was written about him, very short book with illustrations, and I actually read it. It's on my podcast YouTube probably over a little maybe fourteen months ago.

44:33 So it's a it's a twenty minute way to learn a little bit more about Litman Pike that I literally just read the book with a camera on me. I got, I got, you know, I got some compliments on that. So if you want to learn more about Litman and you don't mind hearing and seeing me at the same time, one might be mug Yeah, I filled in for you, get tucked in. Uh, turn on YouTube and away we away, we will will go. So but no, it's a great pick and and probably should be in the Hall of Fame. Maybe someday someone will really vouch and go to bat and justice will be served, and not just livmit By, but some other guys left held, Duel p Rose, you know, all the guys we talked about.

45:23 And that's all right, we're coming down the home stretch. You got another. One, Yeah, this is my last one. This is this is you know, when we talk about best cards, this one straddles the line because it's a postcard, but it's an old postcard, so it's not like it's a new commemorative postcard. And if you love the movie Feel the Dreams, you'll know who this guy is. If you're not a fan of Field of Dreams or a baseball guy, you might not know. But uh, you know Doc Moonlight Graham right in the movie, played by the old version played by Charton and the young version played by Syracuse his own Frank Whaley, who when I was setting up at the regional market many moons ago after that movie was out a few years, came up to my card table just as a regular patron, and I'm like looking at him, like Frank Whaley, and I'm like, oh my god, dude, Field the Dreams is one of my favorite movies. He goes, oh, man, that's cool to hear. And I think he bought something.

46:27 So I sold something to the guy that played Doc Moonlight Graham on Field of Dreams, who's a Syracuse There's been in a lot of movies, but he's a Syracuse native and I think he still has family in the area, so he's here in the area sometimes. So this is a postcard from nineteen oh eight nineteen oh nine by the Rose Company. But you know a lot of stuff that we consider cards now from that error weren't cards in the sense we think of now where they had to come out of packs, right, They could have been newspaper strips, postcards, inserts like the Baltimore News, Babe Ruth.

47:08 So with that in mind, I put this card on the list. And you know how many of bats the real Moonlight grab had was one one one a bat, one at bat, which is where I'm not sure, but uh, he's over. Yeah, so maybe I had two of bats, but he was oh for one, So he did. He did make it out. And it's what that character is based on the Field of dream And listen, did that scene or that's plotline make the movie? No, but it was a huge, a huge part of it, right, anyone that talked who likes Field of Dreams. That's a pivotal moment form. And you have our legendary actor and Charton Heston played them in a well you know another good actor, maybe not in the same venus, but Frank Whalley Junior playing the young version. It's just I love the movie.

48:09 I'm not even a Kevin cost fan, per se, I just love this movie or I love Feeling the dreams Burt Landcaster, I'm saying, I always get Burt. I get my Burt Lancasters and Charton Heston. My bad, sorry Bert Landcaster rest, but I always get those two. Uh Like I'll say one when I'm thinking, I'll say one's name and the other. So yes, but thank you, thank you, Mike Petty. We always have to fact checker, so so so this is and yes, this is not a cheap item, but I we didn't have any kind of financial question.

48:50 Super it is super cool. Matt. You can put this like you can have this in your office and people will come in and be like, what's that? I never even heard of that guy? And you can say, I think you have you ever seen Field of Dreams and the where you go, right, well, I'm not going to tell the host. So yeah, I wanted to put something that wasn't and I knew about this item. And then I actually seen Tony Dimarzios posting a vintage group and he posted and I'm like recently and I'm like, that's that's gotta make this listener should So there you go. Great, pick Maddy quoting the movie. Yep, yeah, there you go.

49:31 I mean the way he just Lancaster describes, you know, the triple that he wants, you know, and wrapping your arms around the base. And I think anybody who's played baseball just you know, it feels for that. Yeah, and you know Stukes is mentioned, Hey, his grave is fifty miles from him. Might be a Jefferson Burdick situation. Now you know, Burdick's grave is twenty two miles seventeen between seventeen and twenty two miles. For me in an area I'm actually quite in a lot anyway. So that's how I kind of started doing that. So I'm a I don't know if anyone's hopefully someone's taking care of that gravesite Stokes, but if not, maybe you know, it could be that guy if if need be, I'm starting to club you are.

50:22 So we're almost at a time we flew through that. I didn't even fine, I'm not gonna lie. I didn't even feel like an hour. Yeah, well that's why I was letting you know, so you have time to land the plane. But I also was inducted by Aliens a couple of years ago. And since then times by. Well, this was cool, this was a fun topic. I learned a lot, first. Of all, Yeah, and that's always good. Yeah. I also learned that I forget a lot. I learned that. I learned that Bert Lancaster and Charton Heston are the same guy until someone calls me. And you can still get a Pete Rose and Bob Feller autograph very cheaply. Yes.

51:03 And you know, even if Pete gets in the hall, I don't think his autographs go up more than that many. I mean, sad but true. All right, say good night John, good night je

Send us a voice message